How Do I Find the Right Personal Injury Lawyer?

In the days and weeks after an accident, everything can feel uncertain. Pain, medical appointments, and insurance calls pile up, and you’re left wondering who’s really on your side. When so much is at stake, choosing the right personal injury lawyer isn’t just another task on your list. It’s the decision that can shape your recovery, your financial stability, and your peace of mind.

At Brassfield & Krueger, we’ve spent more than 75 years standing beside injury victims across Illinois. We’ve seen how the right representation can turn confusion into confidence, and how the wrong lawyer can leave people feeling overlooked and undercompensated. To find the right personal injury lawyer, we recommend you look for someone who:

• Focuses on personal injury law — not a generalist who “does a little bit of everything.”
• Has real trial experience and isn’t afraid to go to court if that’s what it takes.
• Shows genuine care and attention to you and your case from day one.
• Earns strong reviews and testimonials from past clients.
• Is local and understands your area’s courts and insurers.
• Doesn’t charge you upfront — working on contingency, so you pay only if you win.

Each of these factors plays a vital role in getting fair treatment and a fair outcome. Let’s look closer at why they matter.

Does It Matter If My Personal Injury Lawyer Practices Other Areas of Law?

Yes, the different areas of law your personal injury lawyer practices matter tremendously. When it comes to personal injury cases, experience isn’t optional. A lawyer who focuses on personal injury law understands the nuances of accident claims, medical evidence, and insurance company tactics.

Unlike general practice attorneys, these focused lawyers know what it takes to prove negligence and maximize recovery. Their knowledge often translates into stronger, faster results for you. Consider these key advantages:

• Deep understanding of medical terminology and injury documentation
• Established relationships with medical professionals and accident reconstruction teams
• Current knowledge of insurance company settlement patterns and strategies
• Familiarity with specific statutes of limitations and filing requirements

Should My Personal Injury Lawyer Have Trial Experience?

Absolutely. Most personal injury cases settle, but the lawyer’s trial reputation heavily influences how good that settlement is. Insurance companies track which lawyers are willing and prepared to go to court.

If your lawyer has a record of success in front of a jury, insurers are far more likely to offer a fair settlement early on. Trial experience shows confidence, skill, and the willingness to fight for what’s right.

How Do I Know If My Lawyer Actually Cares About My Case?

The best personal injury lawyers treat clients like people, not case numbers. You’ll notice it in the way they listen, explain things clearly, and keep you updated throughout the process.

Watch out for red flags like rushed consultations, vague answers, or poor communication. A lawyer who genuinely cares will make sure you understand your rights and feel supported every step of the way. Look for these positive indicators:

• Prompt responses to your calls and emails
• Clear explanations of legal procedures without confusing jargon
• Regular updates on case progress and next steps
• Willingness to answer questions without making you feel rushed

How Important Are Reviews or Testimonials When Picking a Lawyer?

Client reviews are a window into real experiences. They reveal how a firm treats people, not just how they advertise. Look for patterns in testimonials. Do clients mention compassion, responsiveness, and results?

Positive testimonials and word-of-mouth referrals are often the best indicators that a lawyer consistently delivers both strong outcomes and genuine client care.

Should I Hire a Local Lawyer or a Big Firm for My Accident Case?

There’s a big difference between being one of hundreds of clients at a large firm and being a priority at a local practice. Local lawyers understand your community, know local judges and insurance adjusters, and often provide more personal attention. They’re also easier to reach when you need updates or reassurance, something that matters deeply during recovery.

Do Personal Injury Lawyers Charge Upfront?

A reputable personal injury lawyer won’t charge you up front. Most work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid if you win your case. This setup removes financial risk and aligns your lawyer’s motivation with your success. Still, it’s smart to ask about the percentage fee and any potential case expenses so you know exactly what to expect.

Ready to Find Your Illinois Personal Injury Lawyer?

If you’ve been injured in Illinois, look for a lawyer who combines experience, local insight, and genuine care. Choose someone who listens, communicates clearly, and has a proven record of results for clients like you.

Brassfield & Krueger offers the combination of over 75 years of experience, local presence, and personal attention your case deserves. When you’re ready, reach out to us for a free consultation to discuss your case and next steps.